[Oni]

oh hey look

[Crypt]

Only thing I'd change is the color of the blue-green bar at the top, other than that, it's nice.

[Eclipse]

I like where it's going but it's just not there yet. The header needs to be flatter and the green bar looks horrible. Also the side borders just below @Akane look a little weird.

You're probably still working on the things that I've mentioned but I thought I might as well point them out.

[Saikou]

Logo needs to be flat, too.

[Satan]

Search bar looks out of place, the borders on the buttons are black, white border on search is just, bleh.
Switch the location of the colour chooser and the search bar and it'd look more bueno.

Maybe a new font would look nice too with it, IDK why but the text looks off to me with this.

The colour is okay-ish, but it honestly just seems very off to me.

Having two round notification buttons and one semi-round rectangle for the name seems weird.
also, why are they separate colours? and why does the Logout button have no background that I can see?

Is this Jessie's work? Cos honestly, it looks like he's been doing what I've been doing with Stylish, beyond moving the tabs and search bar.

Only real difference I can see with this.

[Oni]

Search bar looks out of place, the borders on the buttons are black, white border on search is just, bleh.
Switch the location of the colour chooser and the search bar and it'd look more bueno.

Maybe a new font would look nice too with it, IDK why but the text looks off to me with this.

The colour is okay-ish, but it honestly just seems very off to me.

Having two round notification buttons and one semi-round rectangle for the name seems weird.
also, why are they separate colours? and why does the Logout button have no background that I can see?

Is this Jessie's work? Cos honestly, it looks like he's been doing what I've been doing with Stylish, beyond moving the tabs and search bar.

Only real difference I can see with this.

He's only just started. We've been pretty busy so it was hard to coordinate.

Edit: I might make it so Gold members can use the theme as its being made (highly experimental).

[Satan]

He's only just started. We've been pretty busy so it was hard to coordinate.

Ahhh. Well, I wasn't trying to come off as bashing it, just rather critical of it since if I don't like how it looks, I'll have to make another style to work with the updated CSS of the new theme, as well as update my old one.

[Alex]

The icons need to be flat looks fucking weird.

[Customer]

Looks really nice so far, but please change the logo to something flat and not that font.

[Earth]

It is looking alright, obviously still needs work but so far its good.

What are you going to do about MyBB 1.8, can't stick with 1.6 forever. If I was you I would start planning to have all of your modifications/plugins updated to 1.8 and start planning an upgrade in a year or two.