[Nuance]

Got commissioned to make a logo.
He said we wanted something that eludes to a sort of RPG feel.
But he wanted something super minimal and eye catching.

This is what I came up with, let me know what you think.

[Ex094]

The Top right one is spot on, I don't know but it don't feel kinda smooth for me, jagged edges

[zorrophreak]

Definitely top half. I'd say sell both one as a b&w version for alternative uses such as receipts (maybe?) or stamps. The top right is a better logo overall its eye catching, and as @Ex094 said, there are some jagged edges on the sword you might like to fix.

I like the idea for the bottom half, but the lines look kind of "thrown-on-with-mspaint" ish, overlapping other key logo componenents, and just kinda kill the professional appearance to it.

Hope this helps, hope your client likes it too!

[Customer]

I think all of them are nice. Like always of course.

The top ones are my favorite though. The lines on the second one seem a little jagged.

[Aeolian]

Top effort, as mentioned by everyone the top ones suit a more appealing look.

[Bish0pQ]

I like the one in the right upper corner. It looks very nice.

[mothered]

I like the one in the right upper corner. It looks very nice.

Precisely my thoughts too when I first viewed It.

It seems to have the right balance- not overly simplistic and not an overkill.

[Nuance]

Thank you for the feedback everyone.

[Skullmeat]

Top right is the best. Needs to be a bit smoother maybe, but the rough edges give it a sort of rugged feel. Nice work.

[Care]

Top right, but you maybe need to feather and refine the edges and it's really jagged.