[Oblitus]

If you prefer her to the girl you know irl then there's really only one obvious choice imo.
As far as you know though, "she" could be a 40 year old man though so make sure you meet before you do anything. (though the chances are probably fairly low)

Ye, shes def not a pedo, lol. We sc and skype all the time.

Why do people even make these kinds of threads?

For advice?

You don't really need advice from anyone, it's not like you're a bot or something.
You know both girls, that's good, but you're the one who makes the choice depending on who you feel better with, I don't see any point in leaving someone you love for someone that loves you. You're the one who knows both of them more than any else on this forum, this thread was pretty useless.
What kind of advice do you want now?

Not really useless. People who've been in similar situations could give advice and input.

I don't think anyone would go ahead and talk to a girl online when he's already dating a girl in real life but disregarding that;
Even if people have been in similar situations, it's still your life and you're the one who chooses no matter the amount of advises/input you have been given. Not even 1 knows how you feel about any of them, and not even 1 on this forum knows who's better than the other when it comes to attitude, personality, etc.
You're the only one who'll do the choice here, no one else will do it for you.