[cr33pyguy]

Hmm... I'd go with a couple of other people here:
Sonic 06 - I gave it away after putting one or two hours into it.
I personally think Elder Scrolls Online is pretty crap too, compared to what I was expecting.

[Nath]

For me it'd be Ghosts. I was expecting it to be better, clearly I thought wrong.

[mirage]

Sneak King for Xbox 360. BK Games deserves an award.

[Cake]

Call of Duty Ghosts. That game sucks an immense amount of cock.