+- Sinisterly (https://sinister.ly)
+-- Forum: Design (https://sinister.ly/Forum-Design)
+--- Forum: Graphic & Video Design (https://sinister.ly/Forum-Graphic-Video-Design)
+--- Thread: [ Concept ] Core Logo (/Thread-Concept-Core-Logo)
Pages:
1
2
[ Concept ] Core Logo - Kureo - 08-17-2013
![[Image: core_logo_concept_by_neriou-d6ij5ie.png]](http://fc00.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2013/229/1/1/core_logo_concept_by_neriou-d6ij5ie.png){kind=logo}
This logo was not intended for anything special, I just created it so that I could have something to do and to get a little practice in shapes and with the Pen-Tool in Photoshop. I was also trying out some of the new effects and such in Photoshop CC and I also had a few ideas I would like to test out. Now, this is a preview version, hence the background on it. So judge without the background and judge the logo only if you are going to post feedback on it.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Soup_DZ - 08-17-2013
The only thing I like about it is the text. The balance is really uneven and I just don't like it. The idea of it is nice, the execution, not so nice.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Kureo - 08-17-2013
(08-17-2013, 05:41 PM)Soup Wrote: The only thing I like about it is the text. The balance is really uneven and I just don't like it. The idea of it is nice, the execution, not so nice.
Well, we all have different opinions, now don't we? But thanks for the feedback! ( But in the future, could you be more specific what was bad, and what was good? )
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Soup_DZ - 08-17-2013
(08-17-2013, 05:45 PM)Neriou Wrote:I did? That was my first sentence. "The only thing I like about it is the text."(08-17-2013, 05:41 PM)Soup Wrote: The only thing I like about it is the text. The balance is really uneven and I just don't like it. The idea of it is nice, the execution, not so nice.
Well, we all have different opinions, now don't we? But thanks for the feedback! ( But in the future, could you be more specific what was bad, and what was good? )
Everything else was bad. Why was it bad? Because the execution of the idea was poor.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Kureo - 08-17-2013
(08-17-2013, 06:03 PM)Soup Wrote:(08-17-2013, 05:45 PM)Neriou Wrote:I did? That was my first sentence. "The only thing I like about it is the text."(08-17-2013, 05:41 PM)Soup Wrote: The only thing I like about it is the text. The balance is really uneven and I just don't like it. The idea of it is nice, the execution, not so nice.
Well, we all have different opinions, now don't we? But thanks for the feedback! ( But in the future, could you be more specific what was bad, and what was good? )
Everything else was bad. Why was it bad? Because the execution of the idea was poor.
You said what was wrong, but you weren't specific. Like, what was bad about it, what didn't fit. And so on, simply saying that it was an bad execution of an idea you have no clue what is not specific.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Soup_DZ - 08-17-2013
(08-17-2013, 06:12 PM)Neriou Wrote:(08-17-2013, 06:03 PM)Soup Wrote:(08-17-2013, 05:45 PM)Neriou Wrote: Well, we all have different opinions, now don't we? But thanks for the feedback! ( But in the future, could you be more specific what was bad, and what was good? )I did? That was my first sentence. "The only thing I like about it is the text."
Everything else was bad. Why was it bad? Because the execution of the idea was poor.
You said what was wrong, but you weren't specific. Like, what was bad about it, what didn't fit. And so on, simply saying that it was an bad execution of an idea you have no clue what is not specific.
Lolol do you have a problem with people telling you your work looks ugly?
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Exiled - 08-17-2013
(08-17-2013, 11:21 PM)Soup Wrote:(08-17-2013, 06:12 PM)Neriou Wrote:(08-17-2013, 06:03 PM)Soup Wrote: I did? That was my first sentence. "The only thing I like about it is the text."
Everything else was bad. Why was it bad? Because the execution of the idea was poor.
You said what was wrong, but you weren't specific. Like, what was bad about it, what didn't fit. And so on, simply saying that it was an bad execution of an idea you have no clue what is not specific.
Lolol do you have a problem with people telling you your work looks ugly?
Lol, I think you've got a point there.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Cake - 08-17-2013
This is a lot better than your parawild logo. Amazing job Neriou.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Kureo - 08-18-2013
(08-17-2013, 11:21 PM)Soup Wrote:(08-17-2013, 06:12 PM)Neriou Wrote:(08-17-2013, 06:03 PM)Soup Wrote: I did? That was my first sentence. "The only thing I like about it is the text."
Everything else was bad. Why was it bad? Because the execution of the idea was poor.
You said what was wrong, but you weren't specific. Like, what was bad about it, what didn't fit. And so on, simply saying that it was an bad execution of an idea you have no clue what is not specific.
Lolol do you have a problem with people telling you your work looks ugly?
Uhm, no, not really. But I don't really like it when people are childish enough to say something negative about anything in general, without giving a specific reason for it. Simply saying that "Its bad/ugly" isn't specific, its just either lazy or you just post it because you have no reason why you think its ugly.
RE: [ Concept ] Core Logo - Soup_DZ - 08-18-2013
It's ugly because it makes no sense. The balance is shitty, the execution of the idea behind your logo in the way I interpret it makes it look even shittier. There is no meaning behind the logo so what makes you think there will be much meaning to the criticism. My gosh. Is it honestly that hard for you to understand?