+- Sinisterly (https://sinister.ly)
+-- Forum: General (https://sinister.ly/Forum-General)
+--- Forum: The Lounge (https://sinister.ly/Forum-The-Lounge)
+--- Thread: Is this legal/illegal? (/Thread-Is-this-legal-illegal)
Pages:
1
2
Is this legal/illegal? - FreightTrain - 01-24-2017
Kind of a simple question, but I've did some research and haven't really found a definite answer, so maybe someone here can help.
Can you host a leaked database on your own site? I'm referring to a public/semi-public database that has been passed around for a year+
Without giving out too much detail, you would essentially be able to search your username on my site and the result from the database would show. I know it's nothing new, but I have some ideas and this is just the basis of it.
Anyways, can I legally do this? Host a once-private then leaked database on my own site for monetary purposes? The results I was getting online only pointed towards if I was the one who hacked and released the database it would be illegal, but I don't have those skills (yet) .
I'd rather not spend my time creating something if it were to just get taken down soon after it was up. Any help on this is welcome. 
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - pvnk - 01-24-2017
Not legal, but no one would really care.
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - Aeolian - 01-24-2017
The equivalent of stealing a candy bar?
Kidding, this is illegal.
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - Elf - 01-24-2017
But isn't that just like https://haveibeenpwned.com
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - zenith - 01-24-2017
No matter how public the database is. It's still private information from the site.
It's like if you wanna send a girls nudes to someone. No matter how many people have seen it. It's still the girls naked body.
Yes it's illegal. But I'm sure hosts that you pay for won't give a shit. If you are using a free host, then your site will be taken down before you can say "lolichan"
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - Pikami - 01-24-2017
In some countries it is not a crime because it's public domain data.
Just know the laws in your country and area. Of course it’s unlikely you’ll get in any trouble, but you never know. Be safe.
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - sleaze - 01-24-2017
(01-24-2017, 04:14 PM)Pikami Wrote: In some countries it is not a crime because it's public domain data.
Just know the laws in your country and area. Of course it’s unlikely you’ll get in any trouble, but you never know. Be safe.
i'm no law expert, but this is like saying that since i made a torrent of someone's copyrighted music it's now public domain. but then again the definition of public domain may change based on the country.
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - zenith - 01-24-2017
(01-24-2017, 07:18 PM)sleaze Wrote:(01-24-2017, 04:14 PM)Pikami Wrote: In some countries it is not a crime because it's public domain data.
Just know the laws in your country and area. Of course it’s unlikely you’ll get in any trouble, but you never know. Be safe.
i'm no law expert, but this is like saying that since i made a torrent of someone's copyrighted music it's now public domain. but then again the definition of public domain may change based on the country.
It's the opposite of that.
You saying that in regards to databases would make it legal to publicly post them. Because "since they are public, they can be featured by anybody."
Not the case.
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - Wolfsschanze - 01-24-2017
Yeah, it's illegal. Unlikely you'll get in trouble though.
RE: Is this legal/illegal? - sleaze - 01-24-2017
(01-24-2017, 07:48 PM)Zenith Wrote:(01-24-2017, 07:18 PM)sleaze Wrote:(01-24-2017, 04:14 PM)Pikami Wrote: In some countries it is not a crime because it's public domain data.
Just know the laws in your country and area. Of course it’s unlikely you’ll get in any trouble, but you never know. Be safe.
i'm no law expert, but this is like saying that since i made a torrent of someone's copyrighted music it's now public domain. but then again the definition of public domain may change based on the country.
It's the opposite of that.
You saying that in regards to databases would make it legal to publicly post them. Because "since they are public, they can be featured by anybody."
Not the case.
yes, if i did, but that's not what i said i used it as a comparison to what he said. of course if i bought an album and shared it freely it doesn't make it legal.